Even in a pandemic, the work of a propagandist is never done.  

Today’s Post and Courier brings another reason-defying feat of illogic from columnist, and National Review editor, Rich Lowry.  For Lowry, the most important thing we can learn from the abject failure of the administration’s response to the coronavirus is—wait for it—the hypocrisy of “the left.”

Because you see, the fact that critics of the President wanted him to act more swiftly and more decisively to meet a public health threat somehow demonstrates that the charge that the President is an aspiring authoritarian is without foundation.  After all, if he was ignorant and indecisive about an issue of importance then he can’t really be a tyrant since “tyrants aren’t bystanders” and “they don’t have to be pushed to declare a national emergency.” Trump, says Lowry, isn’t an authoritarian but rather “he has a highly personalized view of the Presidency.”

My colleague in philosophy and fellow GSH columnist Larry Krasnoff could no doubt shred this absurdity more concisely and fully than I can (he may well be writing at this moment) but let us consider just two points:

  1. Authoritarian leaders do not generally assert control and bypass legal restrictions with regard to all aspects of a political community—this confuses authoritarianism with totalitarianism.  Instead, they establish control with respect to activity that they view as a threat to their power or if they see opportunities to expand their political power.  There is a great deal of relatively free activity in China, until the communist party decides that the activity is a threat to their power.
  2. President Trump did not see the threat of a pandemic as important because he only sees the world through the lens of his own personal interests and power.  This is what helps define an authoritarian ruler.

Further evidence of the rise of authoritarianism is when propaganda replaces honest commentary and debate. Lowry’s column is more than a cheap and baseless shot at “the left;” it is meant to obscure the voluminous evidence that Trump has rejected legitimate legislative oversight, used his office to enrich family and business associates, purged his administration and party of those deemed insufficiently loyal, used the threat of conspiracy to undermine the press and government institutions, and dismissed evidence that a foreign power has and is continuing to disrupt free and fair elections.

3 thoughts on “Pandemic Propaganda

  1. Thanks, Phil. I would add that Trump’s response prior to last week had been totally authoritarian, in that he was telling the American public: don’t believe the independent media, or the medical professionals, believe me (as I tell you what you want to hear rather than the truth).


  2. Indeed. That is a go to play in the authoritarian’s playbook, isn’t it. Very scary when there is no longer even a reasonable approximation of information sources that are respected across a large swath of society. I think this is the area where it is most clear that Trump is the product of 40 years of denegrating experts as arrogant and government as incompetent and sinister. Thanks for the comment. Posting a few depressing bits of misinformation from out President later today.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.